An Iconic Burger Joint Prepares for Its Final Chapter
A beloved fixture of Milwaukee’s downtown food scene, AJ Bombers, located at 1247 N. Water Street, will permanently close its doors in late 2025. Known for its playful atmosphere, inventive burgers, and unique charm, the restaurant has been a staple for locals and visitors alike since opening in 2009.
After more than 15 years of operation, the decision has been made not to renew the lease for the building at the corner of Water and Knapp streets. The closure will mark the end of an era for a place that redefined what it means to be a modern American burger bar.
Known for Burgers With a Twist
AJ Bombers carved a niche for itself through bold and creative menu offerings. One of its most talked-about dishes was the Barrie Burger, topped with bacon and chunky peanut butter—a daring flavor combination that became a local legend. The menu also paid tribute to burger history with items like its version of the Marc’s Big Boy, a nostalgic nod that connected generations of burger enthusiasts.
Beyond the food, the restaurant offered an experience. Its “p-nut bombs” — a quirky system of overhead delivery tubes that launched shell-on peanuts across the room into waiting bowls — made for a signature interaction that left guests both surprised and delighted.
From Local Favorite to National Recognition
In 2010, AJ Bombers gained national attention after appearing on the Travel Channel’s “Food Wars.” The show pitted the restaurant against another local heavyweight in a battle for the title of Milwaukee’s best burger. After a spirited showdown, AJ Bombers took home the crown in a unanimous vote, earning both bragging rights and a surge in popularity.
That victory solidified its status not just as a local favorite, but as a must-visit destination for food lovers across the country.
Why the Doors Are Closing
While the restaurant has continued to thrive in popularity, the decision not to extend the lease was made as part of a broader strategic shift. Operating in a competitive urban environment comes with its own set of challenges, and after careful evaluation, the choice was made to let AJ Bombers sunset on a high note rather than stretch beyond its prime.
The announcement has prompted an outpouring of emotion from loyal patrons, many of whom consider the restaurant a home away from home. With the countdown now ticking, the team behind the brand has confirmed that operations will continue as usual through the end of 2025, ensuring that fans have time to revisit their favorite dishes and celebrate the memories made within its walls.
A Fitting Farewell in the Works
The coming months will be anything but ordinary. A celebratory series of events and promotions is being planned, offering guests a chance to enjoy retired menu items, experience tributes to the restaurant’s milestones, and participate in themed nights that honor AJ Bombers’ most memorable moments.
Whether it’s a final taste of the Barrie Burger, one last peanut launch across the bar, or a photo beneath the graffiti-lined walls, longtime customers are encouraged to come back and be part of this historic farewell.
More Than a Burger Spot
AJ Bombers was never just about the food. It became part of the city’s cultural fabric—hosting casual lunches, college reunions, first dates, and late-night cravings. Its offbeat humor, bold branding, and commitment to delivering an authentic experience made it stand out in a crowded market.
The restaurant’s departure will undoubtedly leave a gap in Milwaukee’s dining scene. However, the impact it made will remain etched in the city’s collective memory.
The Final Months
Though the closing date may seem far away, the next several months promise to be filled with nostalgia, celebration, and appreciation for what AJ Bombers brought to the community. Regulars and newcomers alike are invited to stop by, savor the iconic dishes, and enjoy the atmosphere one last time.
As downtown Milwaukee continues to evolve, AJ Bombers will be remembered not only for its burgers, but for the way it brought people together—laughing, eating, and tossing peanuts through the air in true Milwaukee style.
